Skip to content

Bigger than UTD

I have just this week decided to advertise with FC Business.  The same publication illustrates some recent interpretations of Brand Finance’s values attributed to leading clubs.  I give a synopsis of some  of the major points though the full article can be read here.

The Germans with Bayern Münich jump ahead of Manchester United and become the World’s most valuable football club brand at $860M!

Borussia Dortmund – the Wembley rival to above, achieved 14% brand value growth to $260M

Real Madrid increase its ‘brand value to $621M (Barcelona’s was however hit and faced an $8M drop!)

Turkish and Brazilian brands improve due to their flourishing economies (Galatasaray up to $116M)

Summary table 2013:

Rank

Club

Brand Value  ($M)

Change (%)

1

FC Bayern Münich

860

9%

2

Manchester United

837

-2%

3

Real Madrid

621

4%

4

FC Barcelona

572

-1%

5

Chelsea

418

5%

6

Arsenal

410

6%

7

Liverpool

361

-2%

8

Manchester City

332

10%

9

AC Milan

263

-10%

10

Borussia Dortmund

260

15%

11

FC Schalke

259

-3%

12

Tottenham Hotspur

219

-3%

13

Juventus

180

12%

14

Ajax

162

-12%

15

Inter Milan

151

-30%

16

Hamburg SV

144

-6%

17

Galatasaray AŞ

116

NA

18

Marseille

111

-34%

19

SC Corinthians

103

34%

20

Napoli

101

20%

21

Olympique Lyonnais

101

-16%

22

Fenerbahçe SK 

95

N/A

23

Bayer Leverkusen

90

41%

24

Paris Saint-Germain

85

34%

25

VfB Stuttgart

83

18%

26

Valencia CF

83

22%

27

VfL Wolfsburg

82

25%

28

AS Roma

82

-3%

29

West Ham United

82

17%

30

Newcastle United

81

-6%

31

Aston Villa

80

-8%

32

SV Werder Bremen

79

17%

33

Everton

78

0%

34

Fulham

75

16%

35

Sunderland

72

10%

36

Beşiktaş JK

71

NA

37

Atlético Madrid

67

34%

38

Santos

65

70%

39

São Paulo

62

6%

40

PSV Eindhoven

61

-18%

41

Stoke City

59

6%

42

Benfica

56

NA

43

Sevilla

56

14%

44

Celtic

55

-13%

45

Flamengo

55

20%

46

Internacional

55

8%

47

West Bromwich Albion

54

NA

48

Bordeaux

53

-30%

49

Fiorentina

52

15%

50

Lazio

52

 12%

Don’t cry for me

An unusual event – a player leaving the pitch, crying from emotions, during the game!  Of course, we’ve witnessed tears from players in winning or losing a big fixture – but apart from injury I can’t recall similar.  One of his own fans, for Trabazonspor in Turkey apparently gave the verbal abuse referring to the player’s recently deceased mother. Now bringing mums into disrepute we know can cause reactions!

I cannot say that we as County fans don’t get saddened by the continuing demise of our Club.  Three goals in four minutes, away against Harrogate sends Stockport County towards the foot of the SKrill North.  It seems that the same old vociferous fans chirp up with solutions but it’s fair to say neither they, former managers or Board Directors/Shareholders seem to have the right acumen.  To that statement, I make one exception, Richard Park (who I approached to get more involved with County) – a genuine supporter; and I have to say, I think targeting Ryan McKnight, existing Chief Executive, is misplaced.  Young he might be, but he has fresh ideas and contacts – that appears more than anyone else is bringing to the “Mad Hatters Tea Party!”

Watch it…..

Use of social media remains under the watchful eyes of consultants and employees in the football industry.  However you feel, it has merits and can be a vital part of the mix of marketing communications.  Of course, there are some like our very own Ryan McKnight that could equally highlight where such tools have been detrimental as have former managers like David Jones who I’m led to believe detested online fans forums and banned players from viewing.

FC Business (and Aaron Syed Jaffery) has recently presented some interesting findings.  I comment on those of interest to my activities in UK and Turkey.  Like any other form of strategy, measurement is critical to assess ROI.  I was intrigued to learn myself, that one client (a major Champions League player in Europe) had three countries above its own with more social media followers!  Attracting ‘Followers’ is not enough and that outlook merely represents vanity or an additional channel of communication.  Activation requires more calls to action and tangible results justifying any investment and assessment.

From a selective sample some interesting findings:

–  Manchester United, Chelsea and Arsenal are top three Facebook numbers with Liverpool a close fourth.  Though recent recruits at Manchester City with social media expertise suggest it will climb in this table also.  Crystal Palace is at the foot.

–  On Twitter, Arsenal, Chelsea and Liverpool have top spots with far lower numbers (e.g.  first position Facebook 33M; Twitter 2M).

– Looking across mainland Europe top three FC Barcelona, Real Madrid then Manchester United.  Galatasaray are in fifth though.

– Galatasaray reach third in Twitter however, with 2.7M followers.

Seems appropriate to finish these musings with my Son’s picture sitting on Fatih Terim’s lap in the dugout at Shrewsbury Town as I get starred at for wearing the new County away kit (which apparently resembles a recent Fenerbache away one!).  Watch this space the creativity for social media and tools have no boundaries.

ACV not AVB

The concept is gaining momentum not least through Supporters Direct’s motivation.  In my tenure as director of Stockport County Supporters’ Co-operative we authorised such an approach to Edgeley Park.  It’s fair to say Stockport MBC had no idea what this meant having never faced such a request before.  At least there are precedents now including: Oxford United to Liverpool.

The main attraction, in theory, is that “under recent legislation if a stadium gets an ACV designation, and its owners later decide to sell up, they must first offer fan bodies or other community groups first chance to make an offer for the ground.”.

A current collective of County fans has sought to reignite this proposition. Will they beat Manchester United to it? What I require to fully appreciate is what this will ‘fans’ or ‘financiers’ do after any such notification, to fund any alternative holding?  It will however, hamper asset stripping.